Public comparisons
Policy risk rankings
Every published review starts at 100. Cited concerns deduct points — high weighs more than medium or low. Higher scores rank first. Informational only — not legal advice.
#1 · Signal
Privacy & securityTerms of service
Score91.0Open review
Severity0 high0 med3 low
Risk flags
No major risk flags
Data use
No data-use concerns flagged
Cancellation
No billing surprises spotted
Gotchas
3 findings
3 low
Protections
None cited
#2 · Proton
Privacy & securityPrivacy policy
Score40.0Open review
Severity1 high1 med15 low
Risk flags
5 findings
1 high1 med3 low
Data use
8 findings
8 low
Cancellation
No billing surprises spotted
Gotchas
4 findings
4 low
Protections
None cited
#3 · Proton
Privacy & securityTerms of service
Score0.0Open review
Severity4 high9 med5 low
Risk flags
4 findings
4 high
Data use
5 findings
5 low
Cancellation
4 findings
4 med
Gotchas
5 findings
5 med
Protections
None cited